AI visibility
Are AI visibility platforms like Peec and Profound dead?
Updated November 2026 · Manoj Surya
Quick answer
No. Tracking whether AI names your brand is still useful, because buyers ask assistants before they ask vendors. A score on its own does not tell you what to change. The tools worth paying for show which questions you lose, who wins them, which pages the answers draw on, and what to do next.
Key points
- Answers vary between runs, so treat one number as a rough signal and watch the trend over weeks.
- Prompt volumes for AI assistants are not public, so any volume figure is an estimate.
- The useful output is the lost question, the competitor named instead and the source behind the answer.
- AI answers repeat what Reddit, news and blogs say, so track those too.
- MarketHQ asks your questions weekly in six assistants from $29 a month.
- MarketHQ turns lost questions into a gap analysis and action plan.
Founder of MarketHQ. Building market intelligence for companies that sell to developers.
AI visibility platforms are not dead, but the version that sells you a score and stops there is hard to justify. People are asking the question because answers change from run to run, nobody outside the AI companies knows real prompt volumes, and a number with no next step feels useless. This post explains each doubt and what a tool should do about it. MarketHQ is our product, so weigh our view accordingly.
Why do people think AI visibility platforms are dead?
Three complaints come up most: answers change run to run, prompt volumes are unknown, and a score without actions feels like a vanity metric.
None of these complaints says buyers stopped asking AI for recommendations. They say a single dashboard number is a weak product. Ask the same question twice and the assistant may name different brands. Ask a vendor how often real people type your question and they can only estimate, because the assistants do not publish that data.
The third complaint is the fair one. If a tool tells you that you appear in 23% of answers and nothing else, you still have to work out what to publish, fix or pitch.
Are the vendors themselves going away?
Not from what their own pages show, but the category is changing, and at least one vendor has reshaped its plans.
Peec AI's pricing page lists a Starter plan at $95 a month with 50 prompts, three of its eight listed models, and one country, as read on 2026-11-20 (https://peec.ai/pricing). Higher plans add prompts and countries.
Profound's pricing page, read on the same date, lists a single Enterprise plan with custom pricing and says it retired its Starter and Growth plans for brands in September 2026. The page lists up to 10 answer engines on a daily frequency. Pricing is not published, so we do not quote one.
A price move is not a sign a market is dying. It does mean you should read the current plan before you assume what a tool costs or includes.
Why does a visibility score alone fall short?
A score tells you how you did, not why, and it gives you nothing to act on.
A useful report is a list of questions. For each one you want to see whether you were named, which competitor was named instead, and which pages the answer seemed to draw on. That is what turns a percentage into a to-do list.
Because answers vary, one run proves little. Repeated checks on a fixed question list are more honest than a single snapshot, and a trend over several weeks tells you whether your changes are working.
What should you look for in an AI visibility tool?
Look for lost questions, named competitors, sources, a fixed question list you control, and a clear next step.
Use this list when you compare tools, including ours.
- Full answer text, not just a mention count.
- The competitors AI recommended in your place.
- The sources and pages behind each answer.
- Questions you can write or edit yourself, phrased the way buyers ask.
- Repeated checks so you can see change over time.
- Which engines the plan includes, and what extra engines cost.
- A gap analysis or action plan, so a miss turns into a task.
- Honest limits: no tool can promise a ranking in an AI answer.
Why combine AI answers with Reddit, news and social mentions?
Assistants often repeat what forums, news and blogs say, so the places people talk about you shape the answers you are trying to improve.
If a Reddit thread names a competitor as the default pick, an assistant may repeat it. Seeing the thread next to the AI answer shows you where to reply, publish or correct a claim. A tool that only runs prompts shows you the symptom but not the conversation behind it.
What does MarketHQ do differently?
MarketHQ asks your questions weekly in six assistants, tracks community and news mentions, and turns lost questions into a gap analysis and action plan.
Every paid plan asks your questions weekly in ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity, Grok and DeepSeek. Lite is $29 a month for 10 questions, Startup is $99 for 60 and Growth is $199 for 120. There is no free plan; Lite and Startup start with a 4-day trial and a card is required.
It also tracks Reddit, X, Bluesky, Hacker News, news and blogs, then runs a gap analysis and action plan on the questions where a competitor is named and you are not. We do not cover every engine; check the engine list against where your buyers ask.
What does a useful result look like?
Illustrative example: a project-management tool loses the question "best project tool for a 10-person agency" to a competitor.
Illustrative example: the answer names the competitor and draws on a comparison blog post and a Reddit thread. The action is concrete: publish an honest comparison for agencies, answer the Reddit thread, then check the same question next week. A score of 23% would not have told you any of that.
What are the limits of this view?
We read two vendor pages on one date and are a competitor ourselves, so check current plans before you buy.
We only describe what Peec AI and Profound state on their own pricing pages on 2026-11-20. We have not compared their reporting or accuracy, and plans change often in this category.
FAQ
- Are AI visibility platforms dead?
- No. Buyers still ask assistants for recommendations, so tracking matters. What is weak is a tool that gives a score and no next step. Prefer one that shows lost questions, competitors and sources.
- Why do AI answers about my brand change every time?
- Assistants generate each answer fresh, so wording and named brands can differ between runs. Check a fixed question list repeatedly and read the trend over weeks instead of trusting one run.
- Do AI visibility tools know real prompt volumes?
- Assistants do not publish how often people ask a question, so any volume figure is an estimate. Treat it as a rough guide and focus on questions your buyers plausibly ask.
- Is there a free way to check my AI visibility first?
- Yes. MarketHQ's free one-off check asks ChatGPT and Perplexity up to three buyer questions for your category. Weekly tracking across six assistants is on paid plans from $29 a month.
Related
- Best tools to track brand mentions in AI answers — engines, prices and limits compared
- How to track brand mentions in AI search — set up tracking step by step
- Free LLM mention checker — one-off check before you buy